177 | Can Plant-Based Spreads Fit In A Healthy Diet?
Butter alternatives and plant-based spreads still carry a lot of baggage from the 1990s, but the products on shelves today have changed. In this episode, I’m joined by registered dietitian nutritionist Mandy Enright to take a fresh look at modern plant-based spreads and where they fit in nutrition discussions today.
This episode is sponsored by Flora Food Group, maker of brands including I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter!® and Country Crock®.
In this episode, we cover:
- Spreads health benefits and science support
- Saturated fat and dietary guidance
- Spreads as a practical tool for patient care
- How to position spreads to your patients
Resources:
- Learn more at the I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter! Wellness Hub at icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com for recipes, smart swaps, and additional nutrition resources.
- Holiday Recipes
- American Heart Association Life's Essential 8
- 2026 Dietary Guidance to Improve Cardiovascular Health
- Scoping Narrative review on Seed oils
- A Secondary Analysis of a Randomized Placebo-Controlled Crossover Trial
Any Questions? Send Me a Message
Connect with Colleen:
Instagram
LinkedIn
Sign up for my FREE Newsletter - Nutrition hot-topics delivered to your inbox each week.
Disclaimer: This podcast is a collection of ideas, strategies, and opinions of the author(s). Its goal is to provide useful information on each of the topics shared within. It is not intended to provide medical, health, or professional consultation or to diagnosis-specific weight or feeding challenges. The author(s) advises the reader to always consult with appropriate health, medical, and professional consultants for support for individual children and family situations. The author(s) do not take responsibility for the personal or other risks, loss, or liability incurred as a direct or indirect consequence of the application or use of information provided. All opinions stated in this podcast are my own and do not reflect the opinions of my employer.
When you hear the words plant-based spread, what immediately comes to mind? If you said margarine from the 1990s, you're definitely not alone. I polled my Instagram audience this week, and 40% said margarine was the first thing they thought of. But here's the problem: our perception of these products may be a little stuck in the past. Welcome back to the Exam Room Nutrition Podcast. I'm your host, Colleen Sloan. I'm a PA and dietitian, and today's episode is sponsored by Flora Food Group. And I'm really excited to partner with them for a conversation that challenges some of that old thinking. Flora Food Group has roots in food dating back to 1871 and makes culinary essentials for cooking, baking, spreading, and more, including brands you probably already recognize, like I Can't Believe It's Not Butter and Country Crock. Now, modern spreads have evolved alongside nutrition science. So today we're taking a fresh look at what's actually in them, what the evidence says about saturated fat and seed oils, and where they may fit into real-world patient care. Joining me today is Mandy Enright, known as the Food and Movement Dietician. She makes nutrition practical, approachable, and realistic. In this episode, we'll also tackle the process versus natural debate, including why butter is more natural, doesn't automatically mean it's better. And of course, we'll share how you can talk through that with patients. I Can't Believe It's Not Butter Wellness Hub has some wonderful recipes and additional resources. Check it out at I Can't Believe It's Not Butter.com and I will link down to it in the show notes. So grab your coffee or drive safe and enjoy my conversation with Mandy. Mandy, I'm so excited to rethink everything we thought we knew about margarine in the 90s and take a fresh look at plant-based spreads. Thanks so much for being here and welcome to the show.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, Colleen. I am so excited to be here.
SPEAKER_00All right, well, we're gonna jump right into it because when so many of our patients or our colleagues hear the word margarine or plant-based spread, they sometimes still picture the products from the 1990s. So I love if you can just open it up with how has this category actually changed over the years?
SPEAKER_01This category has changed quite a bit from what many practitioners may associate with foods from the 90s. Today's plant-based vegetable oil spreads have evolved along with nutrition science and people's needs. These are blends of plant oils and water designed to give you that buttery taste and spreadable texture with less saturated fat than dairy butter. Many also provide essential fatty acids and added vitamins. So I'd encourage clinicians to take a fresh look at what's actually in today's products. These can be useful everyday foods with nutritional benefits rather than an option we might discredit as a diet food because of misinformation or misunderstanding.
SPEAKER_00So what's interesting is I pulled my audience on Instagram and I asked them, like, what do they normally think of when we think of plant-based spreads? And 40% said, you mean like margarine? And so are today's spreads
unknownthe
SPEAKER_00same thing as traditional margarine?
SPEAKER_01They are related, but they're not the same. Both margarine and spreads are made from blends of plant-based oils and water. However, margarine has a standard of identity requiring at least 80% fat. Vegetable oil-based spreads aren't required to meet that same standard, so they can actually come in different fat levels. That's why you might see a light version of a spread along with an original version. And that really gives people options depending on their nutrition goals and how they plan to use the product.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so let's get a little nerdy and talk about how are these spreads actually like spreadable? Because if they're made with oil and water, clarify that a little bit for me.
SPEAKER_01Ultimately, it comes down to how the ingredients all work together. We have emulsifiers that help oil and water stay blended. So some solid fat that provides structure. It's that combination creating a smooth product that holds together and creates that spreadability. Each ingredient has a job. The oils contribute those beneficial fatty acids plus vitamins and minerals for nutritional fortification.
SPEAKER_00All right, let's talk about the elephant in the room because when you talk about plant-based spreads, there's sometimes a lingering concern. And again, I think this goes back to like the 90s. And it's that concern of partially hydrogenated oils and trans fats. So are those still in the food supply?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you and you nailed it again, a lot of these perceptions from the 90s that are maybe still lingering out there. So partially hydrogenated oils contain trans fats. And yes, at one time they were used in many foods, primarily to help improve shelf life. But the FDA banned partially hydrogenated oils in foods back in 2015. So trans fats from partially hydrogenated oils are no longer found in foods here in the US.
SPEAKER_00So another thing that I told my audience was asking them about processing. And one of the most common questions that my audience and clinicians are getting from their patients are that these foods are processed. And it's sort of becoming like this bad word of food, and people want to avoid things that are processed, and it carries a lot of weight with our patients. And so what is processing accomplish in a vegetable oil-based thread?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like you said, a lot of people tend to associate the word processing with being something quote unquote bad or unhealthy. But the thing to note is that processing actually serves some very practical purposes here, primarily to improve the safety, stability, and functionality. Refining vegetable oils helps to remove impurities, unwanted flavors, and contaminants while preserving the fatty acid composition. So, for your clinician listeners out there, when a patient hears the word processed, I'd explain what that processing is actually accomplishing. In this case, it's helping to make a safe, consistent product that's convenient to use. And then we can look at the nutritional profile, including the kinds of fat it provides, and really focusing more on the benefits.
SPEAKER_00Mandy, I hope you're ready because I'm going to throw another big hot topic at you, and this is talking about seed oils. And it's super controversial. I'm really glad though that in the medical field, amongst most of my colleagues, we are in alignment, but there's still so much misinformation regarding seed oils, inflammation. There's words thrown out there like toxic, poisonous by a lot of different social media influencers. And so, what does the evidence actually tell us about seed oils and inflammation?
SPEAKER_01The human evidence does not support that seed oils cause inflammation. In fact, replacing saturated fats with polyunsaturated fats, including those found in seed oils, is associated with better cardiovascular health. As we saw in the American Heart Association Dietary Guidance that was released earlier this year, it reinforces that choosing sources of unsaturated fats in place of saturated fats help support heart health, lower heart disease risk, and may even help lower blood pressure. And the evidence doesn't stop there. A 2026 review of the human evidence found that common claims linking seed oils and linoleic acid to inflammation weren't supported by the overall evidence. There are also meta-analyses of randomized trials that have found that increasing linoleic acid did not significantly increase common markers of inflammation.
SPEAKER_00Okay, I love that you brought in the evidence. And I, when I talk about this with my clinician colleagues, I think it's really important to go back to the evidence. So how do we do that? How do we like explain evidence to lay public and to our patients so that they understand it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, again, it is really about bringing that conversation back to the evidence, but more importantly, it's how it fits into an overall eating pattern. And rather than saying that patients have to avoid an entire category of oils, really focusing again more on what are the benefits that you're getting from them.
SPEAKER_00I like that reminder too, overall eating pattern, because we know that that's truly what matters, not necessarily the one food item that they're eating. So I think that's a really good point. So another argument that I hear all the time on social media is that butter is more natural. So therefore, it must be healthier. So how do we respond to that?
SPEAKER_01I mean, Colleen, you can also argue that butter is a processed food because it didn't come out of the cow directly in stick form. So, you know, here's a fun fact soybean oil on its own meets the FDA's definition of healthy. And that means that when it's used in spreads, this healthy oil helps provide omega-3 fatty acids. At the end of the day, we have to bring it back to the fat content and what is someone's overall health goal, whether it be lowering their blood pressure or their LDL cholesterol. The American Heart Association's Life's Essential 8 reinforces that limiting foods like butter and swapping for sources of unsaturated fats is actually going to be what is going to reach those health goals. So when we compare the two, per tablespoon, butter contains seven grams of saturated fat, whereas a spread can contain anywhere from 70 to 80% less saturated fat than butter. And that's pretty significant for someone who's looking to reduce their saturated fat intake. That doesn't mean one food defines somebody's entire diet, right? Just like we said, it's really about considering the overall pattern and what is it that we are swapping in place of. So if somebody really wants a like that buttery taste with less saturated fat, a vegetable oil-based spread is gonna be a practical option.
SPEAKER_00I'm really glad that you brought up saturated fats because again, going back to when I pulled the audience, I asked them like what is the most important thing when they are recommending a cooking oil or a spread to their patients. And 60% said the saturated fat profile. So I really think that plant-based spreads fill in this need really nicely here. And so beyond, you know, having less saturated fat, which I think is really incredible, what else do modern plant-based spreads contribute nutritionally?
SPEAKER_01Great news is you're getting essential fatty acids such as omega-3 ALAs and omega-6's linoleic acid. And depending on the variety, spreads could also be fortified with vitamins A, D, E, B12, and some even include calcium. And these are nutrients that are helpful when we're looking at somebody's dietary needs. So for example, a tablespoon of I can't believe it's not butter original provides 20% of the daily value of vitamins A, D, E, and B12. And product formulations will vary. So I would recommend always checking that label for the nutrients that matter to that particular patient.
SPEAKER_00So coming back to like some of our patients who are trying to follow a heart-healthy diet, I love how you mentioned swaps. And I always tell patients like you're one tweak away from a great diet. And so, how can replacing butter with a plant-based spread help without requiring that complete diet overhaul?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like you said, it's just a small swap that's letting people keep their routine familiar. They can still have a buttery spread on toast or tossed in with vegetables while reducing that saturated fat content. In fact, I can't believe it's not butter original, even has a heart check certified by the American Heart Association as a heart-healthy food. And the research supports that swaps really are a viable option for people because a 2025 study following more than 220,000 adults found that just replacing 10 grams of butter a day, which is just a little less than a tablespoon, with plant oils was associated with an estimated 17% lower risk of death. Just to note, that was an observational study of butter and plant oils. So it doesn't necessarily establish a cause and effect or testing one particular spread.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so let's go to the exam room with some of my colleagues. If they're face to face with a patient, this is when it really matters, right? We can talk about the science, we can talk about all the nerdy ingredients and things like that. But patients need practicality, and my colleagues listening really appreciate some talking points and some tips for the patients. So, one, when would you recommend a plant-based spread to a patient and then how can they use it?
SPEAKER_01Dietician, I consider recommending a plant-based spread to someone who wants to reduce their saturated fat, but really genuinely enjoys the taste and convenience of butter. So we can start with something that they're already eating, whether they had toast in the morning, they love a baked potato, or there are some cases where we have to address things like allergies. There might be somebody who can't have dairy for whatever reason. And those dairy-free varieties can be really useful. I like to match the product to the patient needs and always, always, always want to go over reading the label with our patients. So when they are in the store and they don't have me with them, they know what to look for. And the goal is really about giving realistic options that fit their meals and their preferences so that the change feels manageable and achievable.
SPEAKER_00All right, let's talk about how these fit with like convenience, budget, which is a big one right now, and dietary needs overall.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I have to say, convenience really is a big part of the appeal. One plant-based spread can work for spreading, you can cook with it, and even depending on the formulation, you could bake with it. And that can really simplify shopping and meal prep. Spreads can also be an affordable option, although prices can definitely vary by store and region. And then from that dietary needs standpoint, there's different fat levels, there's fortified options. As I mentioned, there are even dairy-free options. So I'd help the patient compare the labels and choose one that best fits their budget, the way that they like to cook, the foods they like to have, and accounting for any dietary restrictions. It's like I said, it's really about finding something that they're actually going to use if they're going to spend their money on it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, for real. And it's a really good swap for people who like that buttery flavor, like you had mentioned. You know, it's a same flavor swap. So I think it's kind of a no-brainer for them. All right, let's talk about patients who are on GLP1 medications or obesity management medications who might be eating smaller quantities of food. Are these types of plant-based spreads useful for them?
SPEAKER_01They absolutely are useful because what these plant-based spreads are doing is helping to make every bite count. When someone is eating smaller amounts, it's helpful to consider what those foods contribute nutritionally. And as I mentioned, some of those spreads are helping to provide those additional vitamins of A, D, E, and B12, along with that omega-3 ALA. And like I said, some varieties might even include calcium. When it comes to GLP1s, I like to teach people what I call the P plus 3F method. So that's protein, fiber, fats, and flavor. We know protein is a priority for people on GLP 1s. So a fortified spread could be useful when you're cooking proteins or high fiber foods like veggies while providing a source of healthy fats and flavor. A plant-based spread is just one part of supporting nutrition rather than something that's going to single-handedly meet all of someone's needs on its own.
SPEAKER_00Okay, let's get really practical. You've mentioned using spreads on toast, and I feel like that's where a lot of people's minds go. But where else can they work in a patient's, you know, day-to-day or maybe cooking or meal prepping?
SPEAKER_01Dietician, I have to say that I personally use these spreads in my own kitchen. And that's honestly because my husband has high triglycerides. So cutting back on saturated fat is always top of mind in my household. I use spreads often and I add flavor when I'm cooking eggs. They also add that nice buttery flavor to cooked vegetables, potatoes, or any other side dish I might be making that day. And some spreads actually work really well in baking and some formulations will come in stick form, which I personally love when I'm baking because I am one of those people who is horrible about remembering to take my butter out and let it soften. And the great thing is that the spreads
unknownthat
SPEAKER_01come in stick form are pretty much ready to go straight from the fridge. So, like I said, the key is all about choosing the formulation for the job at hand. And because spreads come in different fat levels, I check the package directions when baking rather than just assuming it's always going to be a one-to-one swap. Again, back to the budget conversation that versatility is really useful for someone who wants one product that's going to be able to handle several meals while still getting less saturated fat than butter.
SPEAKER_00So, how do we talk about these spreads to a patient who's maybe never considered using one? How would you bring this up? How would you explain it to someone like that?
SPEAKER_01I am a massive advocate of habit stacking. So just like anytime we want someone to change or start a new habit, it's always best to find that lowest point of entry and stack onto something they're already doing. So we've talked a lot about toast. If someone tells me that they have toast with butter every morning, or maybe they find that when they cook vegetables, it's really bland, I might ask them, hey, would you be open to trying a plant-based spread on your toast or mixing some into your vegetables? It it's going to give you that buttery taste with less saturated fat. And then again, we can look at those labels together and choose the variety that best fits their needs. I always like to say it's just always starting with that familiarity, that one familiar food makes it a really easy experiment rather than asking them to make a massive change at once.
SPEAKER_00And I also think about the older adult population, right? Their sense of taste tends to decrease. And often they're adding salt to their meals, which is kind of the opposite of what we're going for. And so I love that just adding a little bit of these plant-based spreads can add that flavor that they're looking for. So I love that. Okay, so a lot of my colleagues are guilty of just telling the patients to choose a healthy fat because that's ultimately what our guidelines say. So what is lacking in that recommendation?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so we have to be careful about oversimplifying or just assuming people know what is considered a healthy fat, right? Like you said, just saying choose healthy fats doesn't inform somebody what they should be buying or what they should ultimately be changing at their meals. I'd be really specific. Instead of just saying replace a source of saturated fat with a source of unsaturated fat, I'd give them an example based on their current eating habits, like using a plant-based spread on a baked potato, or as we mentioned, maybe spreading some onto that morning toast. I'd also say it's helpful to explain that we're talking about a slot for unsaturated fats rather than saying they need to cut something out completely. Patients need an action they see themselves doing and repeatedly doing. And that's where specific food examples based on their current habits can make our guidance much more useful and actionable.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's November, so we're coming up to the holidays. This is my favorite time of year. I think everyone loves this time of year and all the seasons and gatherings that we have. Do you have any helpful tips for eating over the holidays and how we can incorporate some of these plant-based spreads?
SPEAKER_01Oh, of course I do. First of all, I love the foods and traditions of the holidays, and I never want to cut out a family favorite recipe. But let's be honest, some of the recipes around the holidays can be a little notorious for their butter content. The great thing about plant-based spreads is that we can make those small swaps without sacrificing flavor or family tradition. So we think about dishes like mashed potatoes, where using a plant-based spread still provides that buttery flavor. And now you're getting more nutrients like omega-3, ALA, and vitamin D. Of course, I'd like to encourage keeping the potato skin on as well for added flavor and fiber stuffing. Without a doubt, my absolute favorite side dish. So using plant-based spreads to saute the veggies reduces saturated fat while also helping to provide moisture and a great buttery flavor. And I don't know about you, Colleen, but to me, the best part of the holidays is always about the desserts. Right? So using plant-based spreads like I can't believe it's not butter extra creamy sticks in a pie crust or pumpkin pie filling, or using I can't believe it's not butter original in a high fiber dessert like baked apples does help to increase the nutrient density of those holiday favorites. So my biggest takeaway for clinicians here is that the holidays bring people together with many different needs or goals. And swapping butter for a plant-based spread can be a really effective way to help meet a lot of those nutrition goals without sacrificing flavor or tradition.
SPEAKER_00So, Mandy, if you could correct one misconception that clinicians themselves still have about plant-based spreads, what would it be?
SPEAKER_01I'm gonna bring it back to where we started, Colleen. They're not stuck in the 90s. This category has evolved, and we should evaluate current formulations and their current nutrition and ingredients. Vegetable oil-based spreads can offer that buttery taste, a convenient texture with less saturated fat. And as we talked about, in some varieties, you're getting added vitamins and essential fatty acids. So I'd like clinicians to see it as a practical option they can consider for the right patient rather than dismissing the category based on an outdated impression.
SPEAKER_00Oh, Mandy, this has been such a cool conversation. I've really loved having an update on these plant-based spreads and really learning how they're not stuck in the 90s and we really shouldn't be either. They can be a wonderful option for so many of our patients. And I'm really excited to try some of these holiday recipes. And I will absolutely link down in the show notes for you guys if you wanted to pull some recipes for yourself or for your patients. Check out the recipes in the show notes and a lot of other resources provided by I Can't Believe It's Not Better. So, Mandy, thank you so much for the gift of your time. I really appreciate you unpacking the evidence behind using plant based spreads.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, Kellyanne. And that's I had a great time chatting with you today about it.
SPEAKER_00And thank you guys for carving out some time for nutrition today. I will see you next week.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
RSS Feed